Make Your Own “Way Better Than Canned” Pumpkin Puree

This post may contain affiliate links. Click here for full disclosure.

Make Your Own Pumpkin PureeDon’t you just love pumpkin? Pumpkin donuts, Pumpkin Poundcake, Pumpkin Spice Lattes, Pumpkin Flan. And especially Pumpkin Pie. With real whipped cream. Do you ever ask yourself at Thanksgiving why you never make pumpkin pie at any other time of the year? I do. Every. Single. Year. But no longer! Now I have pumpkin cubes canned in my pantry. I just drain the water and throw the cubes into my handy dandy Ninja food processor, and voila! Pumpkin Puree. So now I can just grab a jar anytime I want to and make a *gasp* “out of season” pumpkin pie. I’m such a rebel!

But not everyone cans. Yet. And since we all love everything pumpkin, I thought I would give you a how-to on making your own WAY better than the canned stuff Pumpkin Puree. I have several recipes on the blog that call for pumpkin puree, so I thought, why not? It’s not that hard. Or time consuming. You can absolutely use canned pumpkin, (which is usually Butternut Squash btw), in any of the recipes here on the blog. I have measurements for both. 🙂 But it’s always fun to make your own.

But, first things first. PLEASE do not can pumpkin puree. If you want to can pumpkin or other winter squashes, you have to can them in cubes. It’s just not safe any other way. You can read all about why at the National Center for Home Food Preservation website here.

Make Your Own Pumpkin Puree

Now, on to the puree!

First of all, preheat your oven to 375° F. Then get a really big knife and cut the pumpkin in half in either direction.

pumpkin insides

pumpkin insides

Scoop out all the seeds and stringy stuff and put them in a bowl so you can roast the seeds later.

Make Your Own Pumpkin Puree

these guys are gonna be so yummy later!

Now coat the cut edges of the pumpkin with butter or coconut oil or olive oil.

butter it up good

butter it up good

Place the cut pieces on a rimmed cookie sheet because it may drip a little. They can be right side up or upside down. Which ever way floats your boat. Put it in the oven for 45 minutes to an hour. If you can stick a fork through it it’s done.  🙂

How To Make Your Own Pumpkin Puree

I stuck a fork in ’em. They’re done!

Now you can scoop the insides away from the outsides easily. Put the insides in a blender or food processor and blend until smooth. Put the outsides in the compost pile or chicken coop.

all smooth and ready to use

all smooth and ready to use

And now you have pumpkin puree for all the tasty pumpkin recipes in cyber space. This one made right at 3 cups, which is perfect for my Pumpkin-Thyme Soup recipe. You can do more than one at time of course. Just make sure there is a little space between them for heat circulation.

So now you know how to make your own pumpkin puree. Go forth and make Pumpkin Spice Everything!


More amazing things you should bake:

How To Make Your Own Pumpkin Puree



7 comments on “Make Your Own “Way Better Than Canned” Pumpkin Puree

    • Hi Sara! You certainly can freeze the puree! I would freeze it in 1 cup portions since some recipes call for one cup. You could put it in baggies or canning jars if you have them. If you use a jar, make sure you leave about 2 inches of headroom so it doesn’t crack the jar as it freezes. Let it thaw completely before using. Thanks for stopping by! 🙂

    • I grew a bunch of pie pumpkins in my garden this year – first time! I just baked the pumpkins in the oven and mashed them up with my immersion blender. I put the puree in those oblong Rubber maid Freezer containers and put 2 cups of puree in each one, then put them in the freezer. I have used the puree in pumpkin bread and pumpkin sheet cake. The only thing you have to do is let the pumpkin thaw, and I pour it into a metal sieve and let it drain whatever liquid has accumulated when thawing. I hope this helps!

    • Hi Michelle! Pumpkin for canning should be cut into 1 inch cubes. A quart jar of cubes yields about 2-3 cups after draining and mashing. I don’t have a post up yet for canning pumpkin, but you can follow the process from the National Center for Home Preservation website. Thanks for stopping by!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *